Mayor's Weekly Message

34, 36, 38, and 40 Stuart Street, Manly

1 Feb 2013

There have been houses on properties at 34, 36, 38 and 40 Stuart Street since 1922 – that is 90 years.

Manly Council acquired the heritage listed property at number 34 Stuart Street in 1977 and number 36 in 1998.

The decision made by the last Council to zone 34 to 40 Stuart Street for Open Space had completely ignored the fact that the original 1960s Council decision for these properties was made at a time when Little Manly had a limited amount of open space and the then imminent closure of the old gasworks located at Little Manly Point for high-rise redevelopment.

However, the provision of open space at Little Manly was vastly improved when the former gasworks site was rehabilitated resulting in Little Manly being among the best in the Manly local government area in open space provision.

In December 2007, number 38 Stuart Street was sold to a private buyer who has since built a new home on it with the consent of the courts. It remains in their ownership.

In July 2012, the elected Council, against the advice of its Chief Financial Officer and senior staff, voted to acquire number 40 Stuart Street. Council subsequently paid $4.25 million when it settled the purchase in October 2012.

This purchase has placed the Council in considerable debt and its impacts on Council’s cash-flow have - and will continue to - adversely affect services and programs for the entire Manly local government area.

Although I did not support the purchase of number 40 Stuart Street by the last Council, the majority of present councillors have formed the view that number 40, which is contiguous with the beach, should be retained and added to the reserve but financed from the sale of numbers 34 and 36 Stuart Street. This is because these sites are separated from the beach by the new house at number 38 and are also severely restricted because number 34 is heritage listed and cannot be demolished, thus ensuring number 36 will remain a site with a house on either side of it for the foreseeable future.

Council’s Craig Avenue car park and the dinghy storage facility at the rear of number 34 will not be affected.

The selling of numbers 34 and 36 Stuart Street to enable Council to retain number 40 is a sound decision not least because it is financially sustainable for the whole of Manly, and it will add meaningful open space to Little Manly Beach.

Jean Hay AM

Back to listing